J. Mattingly 1845 “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” Single Barrel Bourbon Private Pick J. Mattingly
J. Mattingly 1845 “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” Single Barrel Bourbon Private Pick J. Mattingly
J. Mattingly 1845 “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” Single Barrel Bourbon Private Pick J. Mattingly
J. Mattingly 1845 “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” Single Barrel Bourbon Private Pick J. Mattingly

J. Mattingly 1845 “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” Single Barrel Bourbon Private Pick

J. Mattingly
Price
Regular price $2.00
Regular price Sale price $2.00
Save $-2
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
  • Secure, Trackable Shipping on Every Order
  • Safe & Secure Checkout - Your info is protected — always encrypted, always private.
  • thoughtfully Packed. Sustainably Shipped. We minimize waste by repurposing cardboard and using recycled materials wherever possible.

Get ready for a flavor-packed ride with “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” — an exclusive single barrel bourbon from the J. Mattingly 1845 Private Barrel Series. Bottled at a fiery 135 Proof (67.5% ABV), this high-octane expression is non-chill filtered and hand-selected for its bold, dessert-like character.

Crafted in Kentucky and Indiana, then bottled in Frankfort, KY, this release offers the deep, indulgent profile you'd expect from a label with a name like “Deluxe Cherry Pie.” Every sip hits you with dark cherry, sweet spice, and toasted vanilla crust, evoking a rich slice of southern tradition with every pour.

🌟 Key Features:

  • Private Barrel Selection: “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!”

  • Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey – no blending, pure expression

  • Bottled at an intense 135 Proof (67.5% ABV)

  • Non-chill filtered to preserve depth and complexity

  • Produced in Indiana & Kentucky, bottled in Frankfort, KY

  • Limited edition – part of the “One Hell of a Pick” collector series

  • Expect sediment, flavor oils, and full-bodied richness straight from the barrel

🥃 Tasting Notes:

  • Nose: Baked cherry, cinnamon sugar, oak char

  • Palate: Cherry cobbler, toasted graham, brown butter, cracked pepper

  • Finish: Rich and long with dark fruit, toasted pie crust, and spice heat

🍸 How to Enjoy:

  • Sip neat in small pours or add a few drops of water to tame the proof

  • Perfect for dessert pairings or as a sweet highlight in a tasting flight

  • A must-have for high-proof bourbon fans and barrel-pick collectors

❓ FAQ:

Q: Is “Deluxe Cherry Pie, Oh My!” an actual flavored whiskey?
A: No, it’s not flavored — this is a naturally complex single barrel bourbon with flavor notes that resemble cherry pie from the barrel and mash profile.

Q: Is this chill filtered?
A: No — it's non-chill filtered, preserving natural oils and flavor sediment.

Q: Is this a limited release?
A: Yes, each single barrel in this series is unique and bottled in very limited quantities.
Shipping information

We can’t ship to PO Boxes or APO addresses right now.

🔔 Please note: This item is non-returnable.

🔞 By adding this to your cart, you confirm that you’re 21 or older. A valid government-issued ID (like a driver’s license, passport, or US Military ID) must be shown at delivery for age verification. No valid ID? Unfortunately, we won’t be able to complete the delivery.
Ask a question

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
California Proposition 65 Notice

Certain products sold on this website contain alcohol. The State of California has determined that consumption of alcoholic beverages may expose consumers to chemicals including ethanol, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm.

⚠️ WARNING: Drinking distilled spirits, beer, coolers, wine and other alcoholic beverages may increase cancer risk, and, during pregnancy, can cause birth defects.

For more information, visit www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/alcohol.
What we think you'll like too!
More from J. Mattingly
More from Single Barrel
Sale
The Blanton Sazerac Bundle includes Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon and Sazerac Rye Full Proof 125 Proof, both from Sazerac, featuring rich amber spirits in iconic bottles.
Blanton Sazerac Bundle: Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon , Sazerac Rye Full Proof Straight Rye Whiskey 125 Proof Sale price $139.99 Regular price $224.99 Save $85
Sale
A bottle of Knob Creek Cask Strength Single Barrel Select – "Main Street Liquor" Private Barrel Pick with a black cap, gold and black label, and amber liquid visible through the clear glass.
Knob Creek Cask Strength Single Barrel Select – "Main Street Liquor" Private Barrel Pick Sale price $69.99 Regular price $79.99 Save $10
A 750ml bottle of Nulu 8 Year Single Barrel Maple Brûlée Bourbon 'Wheated Peanut Butter Pancake' (109.2 proof) features a dark label with gold and white text and a wax-sealed cap.
Nulu 8 Year Single Barrel Maple Brûlée Bourbon 'Wheated Peanut Butter Pancake' 109.2 Proof $104.99
Sale
A 750ml bottle of Nulu 8 Year Single Barrel Double Oaked Wheated Bourbon “Old Fashioned” 111.6 Proof, non-chill filtered, with a blue wax seal and a gold medal sticker on the label.
Nulu 8 Year Single Barrel Double Oaked Wheated Bourbon “Old Fashioned” 111.6 Proof Sale price $104.99 Regular price $129.99 Save $25
Sale
Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon 750ml - Main Street Liquor
Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon 750ml from $109.99 Regular price $179.99 Save $70
Recently viewed
Back to Single Barrel

Our online liquor store offers a wide selection of premium spirits including bourbon, whisky, tequila, vodka, rum, scotch, and limited-edition releases. We specialize in hard-to-find bottles, allocated bourbons, gift sets, and custom engraved liquor bottles. Product availability may vary by state due to alcohol distribution regulations, but we continuously update our inventory to provide access to top-rated and collectible spirits online.

All liquor orders are shipped directly from licensed retailers within our fulfillment network. Orders are carefully packaged to protect the bottle during transit and shipped using approved carriers that allow alcohol delivery. An adult aged 21 or older must be present to sign for the package at delivery. Shipping times vary depending on your location, product availability, and state regulations, but tracking information is provided once your order ships.

Yes, liquor makes an excellent gift, and we offer gift-ready options including custom engraved bottles, personalized messages, and premium gift packaging. Engraved liquor bottles are popular for birthdays, weddings, corporate gifting, holidays, and special occasions. When gifting alcohol, the recipient must still be 21 or older and available to sign for delivery. Pricing, engraving styles, and availability vary by product.

All bottles sold on our site are 100% authentic and sourced from licensed retailers and authorized suppliers. Our pricing reflects current market conditions, including rarity, age, and availability of allocated spirits. While some limited releases may carry premium pricing, we focus on transparency, quality, and access to bottles that are often unavailable in local liquor stores. We frequently offer promotions, bundle deals, and exclusive releases for online customers.

Yes, we specialize in allocated and hard-to-find bourbons and whiskies that are often unavailable at traditional liquor stores. Our selection includes limited-release bourbon, single barrel picks, small batch whiskies, and collectible bottles from highly sought-after distilleries. Inventory for these bottles is limited and changes frequently due to demand, so availability is first-come, first-served. We recommend joining our email list or checking back often to stay updated on new releases and exclusive drops.