10 Best Ways to Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey
Some flavor combinations are so unexpectedly perfect they make you wonder why no one thought of them sooner. That’s exactly the case with peanut butter whiskey. This sweet and savory spirit has created a huge splash, becoming the go-to for fun shots, creative dessert cocktails, and cozy nightcaps. It’s a playful and versatile addition to any home bar, offering a familiar, nostalgic flavor in a whole new way. If you’re curious about what all the excitement is about, you’ve come to the right place. We’re covering everything from its surprising origins to the best ways to drink it, helping you find your perfect bottle.
Key Takeaways
- It's a Flavored Whiskey, Not a Traditional Bourbon: Approach peanut butter whiskey as a sweet, creamy spirit that's more like a liqueur. Its dessert-like profile makes it a fun mixer and an easy entry point for newcomers, rather than a substitute for your favorite rye.
- Its Versatility Shines in Simple Mixes and Cocktails: You don’t need complex recipes to enjoy it. Start by sipping it on the rocks, mixing it with cream soda, or adding a splash to hot chocolate before trying it in creative dessert cocktails like a Peanut Butter Old Fashioned.
- Don't Forget Food Pairings: Its sweet and savory notes make it a surprisingly great match for food. Drizzle it over vanilla ice cream for an effortless dessert, or pair it with salty snacks like pretzels and sharp cheddar to balance its sweetness.
So, What Exactly Is Peanut Butter Whiskey?
If you’ve seen a bottle of peanut butter whiskey on the shelf, you might have a few questions. Is it a gimmick? Is it even whiskey? The short answer is that it’s a flavored whiskey, a spirit that has captured the hearts of sweet-toothed drinkers and creative cocktail makers alike. It’s a fun, approachable spirit that doesn’t take itself too seriously. Think of it less as a replacement for your favorite single malt and more as a unique addition to your bar cart, perfect for mixing, shooting, or sipping when you’re in the mood for something different.
Understanding Its Flavor Profile
Peanut butter whiskey tastes exactly like its name suggests. The experience starts with a rich, nutty aroma that leads into a sweet and creamy flavor profile. You can expect to find notes of honey, vanilla, and even praline, all wrapped up in that unmistakable roasted peanut taste. The texture is another key element; it has a viscous, smooth mouthfeel that’s thicker than traditional whiskey. In fact, its consistency and sweetness make it feel more like you’re sipping on a decadent liqueur or a dessert wine, making it an incredibly easy-to-drink spirit, especially for those new to the world of whiskey.
A Peek into How It's Made
The process for making peanut butter whiskey begins just like any other. Distillers start with a base of raw grains that are malted, mashed, fermented, distilled, and aged to create a whiskey. The magic happens when the peanut flavor is introduced. Contrary to what you might think, jars of peanut butter aren't just dumped into the barrels. Instead, producers use natural peanut flavoring to infuse the spirit. Some brands use a clever technique called "fat washing," where the high-proof spirit is passed through peanuts to extract their oils and signature flavor, resulting in a smooth, nutty finish without any actual solids.
Clearing Up Common Myths
Let’s clear up a couple of things. First, peanut butter whiskey is a flavored whiskey, which puts it in a different category from traditional American whiskeys like bourbon or rye. Legally, straight American whiskey cannot contain any additives, including flavorings or extra sugars. This is why peanut butter whiskey is labeled as a "flavored whiskey" or "whiskey with natural flavors." It’s also important to know that while it tastes intensely of peanuts, the spirit itself doesn't contain peanut butter. The flavor is infused, creating a smooth, allergen-friendly (in most cases, but always check the label!) spirit that captures the essence without the texture.
The Best Peanut Butter Whiskeys to Try Now
With so many peanut butter whiskeys on the market, it can be tough to know where to start. Each brand offers a slightly different take on the sweet and nutty flavor, from intensely creamy dessert-like spirits to more balanced options where the whiskey still shines through. To help you find your perfect match, we’ve rounded up five of the best and most popular bottles you can get your hands on. Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey drinker or just curious, there’s a bottle here for you.
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
Often credited with starting the trend, Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey has a fantastic origin story. It was created by a husband-and-wife team, Steven and Brittany Yeng, after a peanut butter whiskey shot became a runaway hit at their San Diego restaurant. Made with real peanuts, Skrewball delivers on its promise with a flavor that’s unapologetically sweet, creamy, and savory. It tastes remarkably like a liquid peanut butter cup, making it an instant favorite for anyone with a sweet tooth. It’s incredibly smooth and easy to drink on its own, but it also serves as a fantastic base for creative, dessert-inspired cocktails. If you want to try the original that started it all, this is the bottle to grab.
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey
Hailing from the mountains of Tennessee, Ole Smoky is known for its authentic moonshines and flavorful whiskeys. Their take on peanut butter whiskey is no exception. It has a rich, creamy profile that tastes just like a freshly baked peanut butter cookie, blended with a smooth whiskey kick. At 60 proof (30% ABV), it’s a bit lighter than some other options, making it a delicious and approachable sipper that won’t overwhelm your palate. It’s perfect for enjoying over ice or as a simple mix with cola or root beer. If you’re looking for a sweet whiskey that’s both comforting and has a gentle kick, Ole Smoky is a fantastic choice.
PB&W Peanut Butter Whiskey
PB&W, which stands for Peanut Butter & Whiskey, is another excellent contender that focuses on creating a balanced and enjoyable drink. This whiskey is celebrated for its smooth texture and distinctly sweet, nutty flavor that makes it incredibly versatile. While you can certainly sip it neat, PB&W truly shines in cocktails. Its straightforward and pleasant profile allows it to mix beautifully without overpowering other ingredients, making it a go-to for bartenders and home mixologists alike. If your main goal is to experiment with peanut butter whiskey cocktails, from a classic Old Fashioned to a creative martini, PB&W is a reliable and delicious foundation for your creations.
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey
For those who enjoy a pronounced nutty flavor, Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey is a must-try. This spirit blends American whiskey with natural peanut butter flavors, resulting in a profile that is rich, sweet, and full of roasted peanut notes. It’s crafted to be exceptionally smooth, making it enjoyable straight out of the bottle, over ice, or as a simple shot. Sheep Dog has gained a loyal following for its bold flavor that stands up well in cocktails while remaining pleasant enough for sipping. It’s a great middle-ground option—not as candy-like as some, but still sweet and indulgent enough to satisfy your craving for a peanut butter-flavored spirit.
Bird Dog Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey
Bird Dog is well-known for its extensive line of flavored whiskeys, and their peanut butter expression is a standout. It features a rich, authentic peanut butter aroma and taste that is beautifully balanced with the warm, underlying notes of barrel-aged Kentucky bourbon. This creates a smooth and satisfying experience that feels both decadent and familiar. Bird Dog’s versatility is one of its greatest strengths; it’s just as good in a complex cocktail as it is poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream. If you appreciate a flavored whiskey where you can still taste the quality of the base spirit, Bird Dog is an excellent bottle to add to your collection.
What to Expect When You Take a Sip
If you’re picturing a glass of classic bourbon with a hint of peanut, you might be in for a surprise. Peanut butter whiskey is a category all its own, offering a unique tasting experience that leans more toward a decadent treat than a traditional spirit. It’s sweet, creamy, and undeniably fun. Think of it less as a replacement for your favorite rye and more as a new, playful addition to your bar cart. Let’s walk through the layers of flavor you’ll discover from the first aroma to the final, lingering finish.
Sweet, Dessert-Like Qualities
The first thing you'll notice is a wave of sweetness that feels comforting and familiar. Most peanut butter whiskeys lead with notes of vanilla, honey, and even caramel or praline, creating a profile that’s very much like a liquid dessert. The texture itself adds to this experience; it often has a thicker, more viscous mouthfeel than you’d expect from a typical whiskey, coating your palate in a smooth, rich layer of flavor. This quality is why many people compare it to a sweet liqueur, making it an approachable and easy-to-sip option for almost anyone.
Creamy and Nutty Notes
Of course, the star of the show is the peanut butter flavor. This isn't just a subtle hint—it's a bold, authentic taste of roasted peanuts that is both savory and sweet. The experience is often compared to enjoying a peanut butter cup, where the nutty, slightly salty notes are perfectly balanced by a creamy sweetness. Brands achieve this flavor using real peanut extracts and flavorings, which results in a genuine taste that’s both rich and satisfying. It’s this creamy, nutty core that makes it so versatile for cocktails and shots that taste like your favorite candy.
The Underlying Whiskey Finish
Beneath all that sweetness and nutty flavor, there is still a whiskey base. While it’s not the dominant flavor, you’ll find a gentle warmth and subtle notes of oak or grain on the finish. Peanut butter whiskey is classified as a "flavored whiskey," which means it often has a slightly lower alcohol content—typically around 70 proof (35% ABV) compared to the 80 proof (40% ABV) or higher of traditional whiskey. This lower proof allows the peanut butter flavor to shine while still providing that satisfying, warm finish you expect from a spirit.
How It Compares to Traditional Whiskey
It’s important to set the right expectations: peanut butter whiskey is not trying to be a complex, single-malt Scotch or a spicy rye. Whiskey purists might not reach for it to sip neat, and that’s okay. Many drinkers think of it more as a flavored spirit or a whiskey liqueur, similar to how they might view cinnamon whiskey. It’s designed to be fun, mixable, and incredibly easy to drink. For those new to whiskey, it serves as a fantastic introduction, while seasoned drinkers can appreciate it as a unique ingredient for creative cocktails or a sweet after-dinner treat.
The Best Ways to Enjoy Peanut Butter Whiskey
Peanut butter whiskey is one of the most approachable and versatile spirits out there. Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey drinker looking for something different or someone who typically shies away from brown spirits, its sweet and savory profile offers a welcoming entry point. You don’t need a fully stocked bar or complicated recipes to start enjoying it. In fact, some of the best ways to drink it are also the simplest. It’s a fantastic spirit for casual get-togethers, cozy nights in, or even as a secret ingredient in your desserts. From straightforward sips to creative concoctions, I’m sharing four of my favorite ways to enjoy peanut butter whiskey. These methods are easy, delicious, and designed to highlight its unique flavor, proving just how adaptable this fun spirit can be. Think of it as your new go-to for adding a little something special to your drinks and dishes.
Keep It Simple: Neat or On the Rocks
Sometimes, the best way to appreciate a spirit is in its purest form. Pouring a measure of peanut butter whiskey neat (at room temperature) or on the rocks (over ice) lets you experience its full flavor profile without any distractions. You’ll notice the rich, nutty aroma and the smooth, sweet finish. For a simple but elegant touch, try serving it in a rocks glass with a smoked sea salt rim. The saltiness beautifully contrasts with the whiskey's sweetness, creating a more complex and satisfying sip. This is the perfect starting point for anyone trying peanut butter whiskey for the first time and really wanting to understand what it’s all about.
Mix It with Your Favorite Soda
If you prefer a longer, more refreshing drink, mixing peanut butter whiskey with soda is a fantastic option. It’s an incredibly simple way to make a two-ingredient cocktail that’s light and easy to drink. Cream soda or Dr. Pepper are popular choices that complement the nutty flavor, but feel free to experiment with your favorite bubbly beverage. For a truly decadent treat, add a splash of chocolate liqueur to the mix. The combination tastes just like a liquid peanut butter cup—a fun and nostalgic drink that’s sure to be a hit at any party or for a quiet night on the couch.
Spike Your Coffee or Hot Chocolate
Transform your favorite hot beverage into a cozy, grown-up treat by adding a shot of peanut butter whiskey. A splash in your morning coffee can add a wonderful layer of nutty sweetness that pairs perfectly with the roasted coffee beans. It’s also an amazing addition to a rich cup of hot chocolate on a chilly evening. The warmth of the drink enhances the whiskey’s creamy notes, creating the ultimate comfort drink. It’s a simple, delicious way to wind down and one of the most comforting spirits to have on hand for a cozy night in.
Drizzle It Over Dessert
Why limit peanut butter whiskey to your glass? Its sweet, dessert-like qualities make it a perfect topping for your favorite sweet treats. Drizzling a little over a bowl of vanilla or chocolate ice cream is a game-changer. The cold creaminess of the ice cream and the rich, nutty warmth of the whiskey create an incredible contrast of flavors and temperatures. You can also pour it over brownies, bread pudding, or even a stack of pancakes. It’s a simple way to add a sophisticated, boozy kick to dessert and makes a bottle the perfect gift for the foodie in your life.
Must-Try Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails
If you’re ready to start mixing, you’ll find that peanut butter whiskey is an incredibly playful and versatile ingredient. Its sweet, nutty profile can put a fun spin on timeless recipes or serve as the star of a new dessert-inspired creation. Whether you’re a seasoned cocktail maker or just looking for a simple two-ingredient mix, there’s a drink here for you. These recipes are straightforward, delicious, and perfect for sharing with friends or enjoying as a sweet nightcap. Grab your shaker, your favorite bottle of peanut butter whiskey, and let’s make some drinks that are sure to become new favorites. From sophisticated sips to nostalgic shots, the possibilities are as fun as they are tasty.
The Peanut Butter Old Fashioned
For a simple yet sophisticated twist on a classic, try a Peanut Butter Old Fashioned. This drink swaps traditional bourbon or rye for the nutty sweetness of peanut butter whiskey, creating a smoother, more approachable version of the iconic cocktail. All you need are two key ingredients: your peanut butter whiskey and a few dashes of Angostura bitters to balance the sweetness. Serve it over a large ice cube with an orange peel or cherry garnish. It’s a fantastic way to introduce a traditional whiskey drinker to the world of flavored spirits, offering a familiar format with a delightful new flavor.
A Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail
If you have a sweet tooth, this cocktail is basically dessert in a glass. It perfectly captures the beloved taste of a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup by combining peanut butter whiskey with a rich chocolate liqueur. Simply mix equal parts of each, shake with ice, and strain into a chilled glass. For an extra decadent touch, you can rim the glass with chocolate syrup or crushed peanuts. It’s a rich, creamy, and satisfying drink that’s perfect for after-dinner sipping or for anyone who believes chocolate and peanut butter are the ultimate power couple.
The Classic PB&J Shot
Bring a little nostalgia to your next get-together with a PB&J shot. This playful concoction tastes just like the classic sandwich, making it an instant crowd-pleaser. The recipe is incredibly simple: just mix peanut butter whiskey with a splash of berry-flavored liqueur like Chambord or even just some cranberry juice. The fruity tartness cuts through the whiskey's sweetness, creating that perfect peanut butter and jelly flavor profile. It’s a fun, easy-to-make shot that doesn’t take itself too seriously and is guaranteed to get people talking.
The Chocolate Peanut Butter Martini
For a more elegant dessert drink, the Chocolate Peanut Butter Martini is a clear winner. This cocktail feels luxurious but is surprisingly easy to whip up. Combine peanut butter whiskey with a quality chocolate liqueur and a splash of cream or a cream-based liqueur like RumChata for a silky-smooth texture. Shake everything vigorously with ice until it’s perfectly chilled, then strain it into a martini glass. Garnish with a few chocolate shavings for a professional finish. It’s a sophisticated and indulgent cocktail that’s perfect for special occasions or when you just want to treat yourself.
A Creamy Peanut Butter White Russian
Give the Dude’s favorite drink a nutty makeover. A Peanut Butter White Russian swaps some or all of the vodka for peanut butter whiskey, adding a whole new layer of flavor to this creamy classic. The combination of peanut butter, coffee liqueur, and cream is absolutely divine. Just pour the peanut butter whiskey and coffee liqueur over ice in a rocks glass, then top it with a generous float of heavy cream or milk. It’s a comforting, cozy, and incredibly satisfying drink that’s perfect for a relaxed evening at home.
The Ultimate Peanut Butter Whiskey Milkshake
When you want to go all-in on indulgence, nothing beats a boozy milkshake. Blending peanut butter whiskey with a few scoops of your favorite ice cream—vanilla and chocolate both work beautifully—creates a rich, creamy, and decadent treat for adults. Add a splash of milk to get your desired consistency, and blend until smooth. Pour it into a tall glass and go wild with the toppings: whipped cream, a drizzle of chocolate or caramel sauce, and a cherry on top. It’s the perfect way to end a meal or cool down on a warm day.
How to Choose Your Perfect Bottle
With so many peanut butter whiskeys popping up, finding the one that’s right for you can feel like a treasure hunt. Not all bottles are created equal—some are intensely sweet, while others let the whiskey notes shine through. Your perfect match will depend on your personal taste, how you plan to drink it, and even your budget. Think about whether you want a smooth sipper for a quiet evening, a bold mixer for creative cocktails, or just an affordable bottle to see what all the buzz is about. Considering a few key factors will help you narrow down the options and pick a winner you’ll genuinely enjoy.
Consider the Alcohol Content
One of the first things you’ll notice is that peanut butter whiskey often has a slightly lower alcohol content than its traditional counterparts. Most are bottled around 70 proof (35% ABV), while a standard whiskey typically starts at 80 proof (40% ABV). This small difference matters. It makes peanut butter whiskey a bit smoother and less fiery, which is why it’s often categorized as a “flavored whiskey” or liqueur. This lower proof makes it incredibly approachable for those new to whiskey and a fantastic, easy-to-work-with ingredient for cocktails, as it blends well without overpowering other flavors. If you’re looking for a gentle introduction to whiskey or a versatile mixer, the typical proof of a peanut butter whiskey is a great place to start.
Compare Different Price Points
You don’t have to break the bank to get into peanut butter whiskey. Most bottles are quite affordable, typically falling in the $20 to $35 range. This accessibility makes it easy to grab a bottle and experiment with different drinks without a huge commitment. Of course, you’ll find premium and craft versions that cost a bit more, often because they use a higher-quality base whiskey or more complex flavoring techniques. If you’re just curious, starting with one of the popular, budget-friendly brands is a smart move. Once you know you enjoy the flavor profile, you can explore more artisanal options that deliver on flavor without stretching your wallet.
Decide on Your Preferred Flavor Intensity
The biggest difference between brands comes down to flavor. Some peanut butter whiskeys are unapologetically sweet and nutty, tasting almost like a melted peanut butter cup. Others offer a more balanced experience, where the creamy peanut flavor complements the warm, oaky notes of the underlying whiskey. Think about how you plan to use it. If you’re making decadent dessert cocktails or want to satisfy a serious sweet tooth, a richer, more intense bottle is perfect. If you prefer sipping your whiskey on the rocks or want a more subtle nutty flavor in your drink, look for a brand known for its balance. It’s similar to choosing a sweet liqueur versus a more traditional spirit.
A Guide for Whiskey Lovers vs. Newcomers
Your experience with whiskey will definitely shape which bottle you prefer. If you’re new to the category, the sweet, smooth, and familiar flavor of peanut butter whiskey is an excellent entry point. It’s fun, easy to drink, and doesn’t have the harsh bite that can turn some people off.
For the seasoned whiskey purist, it’s best to view this as a fun, separate category. It’s not trying to be a single malt scotch. Instead, it’s one of many innovative spirits made using interesting techniques. Many brands use a process called “fat washing,” where the spirit is infused with peanuts to capture the flavor without making it oily. Approaching it with an open mind as a cocktail ingredient or a fun shot can be a surprisingly enjoyable experience.
What Are People Saying About It?
Peanut butter whiskey has certainly made a splash, and it's one of those spirits that gets everyone talking. It’s a bit of a rebel in the whiskey world, and because of that, opinions are all over the map. On one side, you have a growing legion of fans who love its sweet, nostalgic flavor and incredible mixability. They see it as a fun, approachable spirit that doesn't take itself too seriously. It’s the perfect ingredient for creative cocktails or a sweet shot to share with friends.
On the other side, you have the traditionalists and whiskey purists who are, let's say, a little more skeptical. For them, the addition of flavorings puts it in a different category altogether—more of a liqueur than a true whiskey. The debate often comes down to a simple question: what do you expect when you pour a glass? Is it a complex, traditional spirit, or is it a fun, flavored drink meant for mixing? The truth is, it can be whatever you want it to be, and understanding the different perspectives is the key to enjoying it for what it is.
The Verdict on Sweetness and Mixability
The first thing you'll hear anyone say about peanut butter whiskey is that it's sweet and, well, tastes a lot like peanut butter. This isn't a subtle hint of nuttiness; it's the star of the show. Because of its bold flavor and sugary profile, many people think of it less as a traditional whiskey and more as a flavored liqueur, similar to something like Fireball. This sweetness is precisely what makes it so versatile in drinks. It’s a fantastic mixer, especially with flavors that complement peanut butter. One of the most popular suggestions you'll find is to mix it with a chocolate liqueur for a cocktail that tastes exactly like a liquid Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.
Why It's a Hit with New Whiskey Drinkers
If you've ever thought, "I'm just not a whiskey person," peanut butter whiskey might be the spirit that changes your mind. Its approachable, sweet, and familiar flavor profile has successfully converted many non-whiskey drinkers into fans. It smooths over the harsh "burn" that can be off-putting to newcomers, replacing it with a creamy, nutty finish. Part of this comes from its classification as a "flavored whiskey," which often means it has a slightly lower alcohol content—typically around 70 proof instead of the standard 80 proof for straight whiskey. This subtle difference makes it an easy-sipping entry point into the wider world of whiskey.
What Whiskey Purists Really Think
Now, let's talk about the whiskey purists. For those who appreciate the strict rules and traditions of whiskey-making, peanut butter whiskey can be a tough sell. Many purists are quick to point out that, by definition, American whiskey cannot contain flavor additives. Since this spirit is clearly flavored, they argue it's not technically a whiskey at all but rather a whiskey-based liqueur. You'll hear some traditionalists damning it for being too sweet or gimmicky. But it's all about perspective. If you're expecting a complex single malt or a spicy rye, you'll be disappointed. If you approach it as a unique, flavored spirit, you're in for a treat.
Top-Rated Brands for Cocktails
When it comes to mixing up cocktails, not all peanut butter whiskeys are created equal, but a few brands consistently get top marks. Brands like Skrewball, Ole Smoky, and Sheep Dog are often praised for their balanced flavor that stands up well in cocktails without being overpowering. They provide that perfect blend of sweet, salty, and nutty notes that can form the base of a fantastic drink. Best of all, it's an affordable category to explore. You can typically find a quality bottle of peanut butter whiskey for between $20 and $35, making it a low-risk, high-reward addition to your collection of spirits.
Perfect Pairings: What to Eat with Your Whiskey
Peanut butter whiskey’s unique flavor—sweet, nutty, and rich—makes it one of the most exciting spirits to pair with food. While it’s great in cocktails or on its own, matching it with the right bites creates some truly memorable combinations. Its versatility goes far beyond what you might expect, bridging the gap between sweet and savory with surprising ease. Think of it less as a traditional whiskey and more as a unique ingredient that works with a wide range of dishes. From decadent desserts to salty snacks, let's explore a few can't-miss ideas that will make you appreciate your bottle even more.
Indulge with Chocolate Desserts
It’s no secret that peanut butter and chocolate are a match made in heaven, and this pairing is just as perfect in liquid form. The rich, salty-sweet notes of peanut butter whiskey cut through the decadent bitterness of dark chocolate beautifully. A simple pour alongside a flourless chocolate torte, a warm brownie, or even a few squares of high-quality dark chocolate can transform a simple dessert into a sophisticated treat. The whiskey enhances the cocoa flavors, creating a combination that tastes just like your favorite peanut butter cup, but with a welcome warmth and complexity.
Complement Ice Cream and Milkshakes
Ready for the easiest dessert upgrade? Drizzle peanut butter whiskey over a scoop of vanilla or chocolate ice cream. The cold creaminess and the warm, nutty whiskey create an incredible contrast that is both simple and indulgent. For something more decadent, blend it into a milkshake with your favorite ice cream and a splash of milk for a boozy, grown-up treat. It’s an effortless way to enjoy its dessert-like qualities, similar to the simple pleasure of a Ready-To-Drink Cocktail.
Experiment with Savory Snacks
Don’t let its sweetness fool you—peanut butter whiskey has a savory side. Its nutty profile and subtle saltiness make it a surprisingly great partner for various snacks. Try sipping it alongside salty pretzels or popcorn to see how it balances the flavors. For a more adventurous pairing, serve it with a cheese board featuring sharp cheddar or smoked gouda. The whiskey’s sweetness provides a lovely counterpoint to the salty, savory notes of the cheese. Even crispy bacon is a fantastic match, creating a memorable sweet-and-savory experience.
Where to Find and Buy Peanut Butter Whiskey
Ready to grab a bottle? Peanut butter whiskey has become so popular that you can find it almost anywhere you buy spirits. Whether you prefer the convenience of online shopping or enjoy browsing the aisles of your local store, you have plenty of options. The key is knowing where to look to find the best selection and prices for your new favorite flavored whiskey.
Get It Delivered from Online Stores
If you value convenience, having your whiskey delivered right to your door is the way to go. Online retailers offer a wide variety of peanut butter whiskey brands, making it easy to compare your options from the comfort of your couch. You can typically expect to spend between $20 and $35 for a standard 750ml bottle, though some premium or craft versions might cost a bit more. Shopping online is a great way to explore different brands you might not find locally and have them shipped directly to you, saving you a trip to the store.
Check Your Local Liquor Store
Sometimes, you just want to hold the bottle in your hand before you buy. Your local liquor store is a great place to find the most popular brands of peanut butter whiskey. You might find something like the Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Gift Set for around $30, which is perfect for trying it out or giving as a gift. One of the best parts of shopping in person is that you can ask the staff for their personal recommendations. They often have great insights into new arrivals or hidden gems you might otherwise overlook, helping you discover a bottle you'll truly enjoy.
How to Find Great Deals and Promotions
Everyone loves a good deal, and you can definitely find them on peanut butter whiskey if you know when to look. Keep an eye out for special promotions and discounts, especially around holidays or major events when retailers often run sales. Signing up for newsletters from your favorite online stores is a simple way to stay in the loop about special offers. Exploring a store’s selection of gifts under $100 can also help you discover some excellent values on individual bottles or gift sets that won't break the bank.
Explore Gift Sets and Subscription Boxes
If you’re looking to really dive into the world of flavored whiskeys, gift sets and subscription boxes are a fantastic way to do it. These curated collections often feature a variety of brands and flavors, letting you sample different styles without committing to a full bottle of each. It’s a fun way to discover new favorites and expand your palate. Our subscription clubs are perfect for anyone who loves trying new spirits, offering a curated experience delivered to you regularly, so there's always something new to taste.
Related Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there actual peanut butter in the bottle? That’s a great question, and the answer is no. You won’t find any solids or thick paste in your bottle. Instead, distillers infuse a whiskey base with natural peanut flavorings and extracts. This process captures that authentic roasted peanut taste and aroma, resulting in a spirit that is perfectly smooth and easy to pour, without any of the texture of real peanut butter.
So, is it really considered whiskey? Technically, it falls into the category of a "flavored whiskey." It starts its life as a traditional whiskey, but because flavors and sweeteners are added after the aging process, it can't be labeled as a straight American whiskey like bourbon or rye. It’s best to think of it as its own unique spirit, similar to a sweet liqueur, designed for fun and easy drinking rather than for whiskey purists.
I'm new to this. What's the simplest way to drink it? The best way to get started is to keep it simple. Try pouring a shot over a large ice cube in a rocks glass. This allows you to taste its unique sweet and nutty profile without any other distractions. If you prefer a longer drink, mixing it with cream soda or Dr. Pepper is a fantastic and effortless way to enjoy it.
Is it safe for someone with a peanut allergy? This is extremely important to consider. While most brands use flavor extraction processes that are designed to remove the allergenic proteins, it's not a universal guarantee. Every brand's process is different, so the safest approach is to always check the label for specific allergen warnings or visit the producer's website directly before you drink it. When in doubt, it's best to err on the side of caution.
Can I just swap it for regular whiskey in my favorite cocktail? You can, but be prepared for a very different drink! Because peanut butter whiskey is much sweeter and has a dominant flavor, it will completely change the profile of a classic cocktail. It works beautifully in drinks that are meant to be sweet and creamy, like a White Russian or a dessert martini. However, swapping it into a spirit-forward classic like a Manhattan will create a much sweeter, novelty version of the original.